Romantasy – the genre-bending fusion of heart-pounding romance and high-stakes fantasy – has exploded from a niche category to a cultural force. With record-breaking hits like A Court of Thorns and Roses (ACOTAR) by Sarah J. Maas and Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros dominating BookTok’s #BookRecs, this genre is redefining modern storytelling. Yet, critics still reduce it to “fantasy with spice.” Time to set the record straight: romantasy is about soul-crushing sacrifices, intricate political schemes, and love stories that reshape entire worlds. Let’s dive into why this genre deserves respect—and tissues.

The Emotional DNA of Romantasy: Where Heartbreak Meets Healing

Sure, some romantasy books are steamy, but the best of them don’t just make your heart race—they rip it out and stomp on it before piecing it back together in the most satisfying way. At its core, romantasy is about deep emotional connections, sacrifice, and character growth, all set against the backdrop of epic world-building.

Take The Bridge Kingdom by Danielle L. Jensen. While it features an enemies-to-lovers dynamic and undeniable chemistry, the heart of the story is about trust, betrayal, and the weight of duty. Similarly, The Serpent and the Wings of Night by Carissa Broadbent isn’t just about romance; it’s about survival, resilience, and the choices that define us.

Pro Tip for Readers: If you loved ACOTAR, try Kingdom of the Wicked by Kerri Maniscalco—a masterclass in blending dark fantasy with emotional gut-punches.

World-Building That Rivals Tolkien (Yes, Really)

Unlike traditional romance novels, where the focus is often solely on relationships, romantasy thrives on intricate world-building. Authors don’t just craft love stories; they create entire magical societies, political intrigue, and mythologies. These aren’t just backdrops for steamy moments; they’re living, breathing worlds that shape the characters’ struggles and triumphs.

Example? Take Crescent City by Sarah J. Maas. Sure, it has an intoxicating slow-burn romance, but its urban fantasy setting is so richly detailed that it feels like a character itself. And let’s not forget The Priory of the Orange Tree by Samantha Shannon, which weaves epic battles, dragon lore, and political drama into its sapphic love story.

Why This Matters: Intricate worlds make the romance meaningful. When lovers fight alongside each other in epic battles (like in Fourth Wing), their bond feels earned—not just a subplot.

Romance as a Driving Force, Not Just a Distraction

Critics of romantasy often argue that the romance overshadows the fantasy. But if we take a step back, isn’t love (in some form) at the heart of most high-stakes fantasy novels? Even in classics like The Lord of the Rings, themes of love, loyalty, and devotion shape the narrative. Romantasy simply embraces these themes while giving them more emotional depth.

Many authors have emphasized that romance in fantasy isn't just an add-on but an integral part of the storytelling. Rebecca Yarros, for example, incorporates themes of power, resilience, and sacrifice in Fourth Wing, proving that romantasy is about much more than just attraction. Similarly, Sarah J. Maas builds relationships that go beyond chemistry—her characters often find partners who challenge and support them, making romance an essential part of their personal and heroic growth.

Tasha Suri, author of The Jasmine Throne, once said, “Romance isn’t a distraction from epic storytelling—it’s what makes the stakes personal. A kingdom at war is tragic, sure. But when the protagonist’s soulmate is on the battlefield, suddenly, the stakes hit much harder.”

Emotional Gut Punches: Why You Need Tissues

Romantasy isn’t just “smut with dragons”—it’s a genre that delivers some of the most gut-wrenching emotional arcs in literature. If you’ve read Kingdom of the Wicked by Kerri Maniscalco or House of Earth and Blood by Sarah J. Maas, you know exactly what I mean. These books make you cry not just because of the romance, but because they explore loss, grief, sacrifice, and healing.

Romantasy takes the reader on a rollercoaster of emotions, making them root for the characters not just as lovers but as individuals fighting their own battles.

What Readers (and Authors) Say

Bestselling romantasy authors have spoken about the depth of the genre:

Rebecca Yarros (Fourth Wing) portrays romantasy as more than just romance—it’s a genre that explores power, resilience, and the battles worth fighting.

Sarah J. Maas demonstrates that romance in fantasy isn’t just about attraction—it’s about finding a partner who challenges and fights beside you, making relationships central to character development.

Carissa Broadbent (The Serpent and the Wings of Night) embraces romantasy as a genre that blends fantasy escapism with deep emotional storytelling, providing both adventure and catharsis.

Why Romantasy is Here to Stay

Romantasy isn’t a passing trend—it’s a genre that has always existed in some form. From the star-crossed lovers of Arthurian legend to the passionate entanglements in gothic fantasy, love has always been intertwined with magic.

What’s changed? Social media has given romantasy a new life, allowing readers to connect, discuss, and share their favorite heart-wrenching moments. Plus, as the genre diversifies, we’re seeing more LGBTQ+ representation, morally gray characters, and unique world-building that challenge the “same old tropes.”

Final Thoughts: It’s Not Just Smut, It’s an Experience

If you’ve ever dismissed romantasy as just “fantasy with spice,” you’re missing out on some of the most emotionally impactful books out there. The best romantasy books don’t just make your pulse race—they make you FEEL. They transport you to new worlds, make you question your own emotions, and, yes, occasionally make you sob at 3 AM because the protagonist just made the ultimate sacrifice.

Let’s clear the air:

Romantasy ≠ Erotica

While some romantasy books include explicit scenes (e.g., A Court of Silver Flames), the genre focuses on emotional and plot-driven stakes. Compare this to erotica, where physical relationships are the primary narrative focus.

Romantasy vs. Traditional Fantasy

Traditional fantasy (e.g., The Lord of the Rings) prioritizes quests and world-building, often sidelining romance. Romantasy makes relationships central to the plot and themes without sacrificing epic stakes.

So next time someone rolls their eyes at romantasy, hand them a copy of A Court of Silver Flames and tell them to come back when they’re done crying their eyes out. 😉

Lit Fic Comparison: Margaret Atwood’s The Blind Assassin weaves romance into a meta-narrative about memory and loss—similar to how romantasy uses love to explore deeper themes.

How to Start Reading Romantasy: A Beginner’s Guide

New to the genre? Here’s your roadmap:

Step 1: Try a Romantasy/High Fantasy Hybrid

Fourth Wing: Dragons, war academies, and slow-burn romance.
Daughter of No Worlds by Carissa Broadbent: Magic, rebellion, and found family.

Step 2: Explore Subgenres

Dark Romantasy: Kingdom of the Wicked (demons, vengeance)
Urban Romantasy: Crescent City (modern magic, noir vibes)
Historical Romantasy: The Witch Collector by Charissa Weaks (folklore, witch trials)

Step 3: Join the Conversation

Follow BookTok hashtags like #Romantasy, #BookRecs, and #FantasyRomance to discover hidden gems and debates (e.g., “Team Rhysand vs. Team Rowan”).

Final Verdict: Romantasy is Fantasy’s Future

Romantasy isn’t a phase—it’s a literary revolution. By centering emotional depth and diverse voices, it’s drawing new readers into fantasy while challenging old stereotypes. As authors like Rebecca Yarros and Tasha Suri push boundaries, expect more LGBTQ+ narratives, intersectional themes, and genre-blending innovation.

What’s your favorite romantasy gut-punch moment? Share below—and check out our Ultimate Romantasy Starter Guide for more recs!

📌 Share the Cosmic Love!

Pin this post on Pinterest or tag me on Instagram (@cosmic.reads.club).

✨ Keep chasing stars & stories,

– Viktoria, Your Cosmic Book Guide

Why Romantasy is More Than Just Smut: Emotional Depth, Epic Worlds & BookTok’s Obsession Explained