From Blood and Ash vs. The Serpent and the Wings of Night: The Ultimate Dark Romantasy Duel
When Blood and Passion Collide
Dark romantasy has become one of the most beloved genres in fantasy literature. With seductive vampires, deadly tournaments, and forbidden love, books like From Blood and Ash (FBAA) by Jennifer L. Armentrout and The Serpent and the Wings of Night (TSatWoN) by Carissa Broadbent pull thousands of readers into their dark worlds. Both stories blend classic fantasy elements with intense emotions, sensual attraction, and the constant threat of death. But which of these books has more bite? Which one pulls you deeper into its magical darkness and keeps you hooked until the last page? Let's compare the two works side by side to see which one reigns supreme.
Premise: Gods vs. Vampire Tournaments
From Blood and Ash
At the center of From Blood and Ash is Poppy, the "Chosen One," who lives a life of isolation. Her fate is tied to divine prophecies, and she is worshiped as a symbol of hope—yet at what cost? Her life is filled with restrictions, preventing her from making her own choices. But when she meets Hawke, a charming yet deadly warrior, her carefully ordered world begins to crumble. What follows is an epic journey where Poppy must battle not only external enemies but also her own doubts and desires.
Tropes:
"Chosen One"
Forbidden love
Religious allegories
Enemies-to-lovers trope
The Serpent and the Wings of Night
This story takes a completely different approach: Oraya, a mortal girl adopted by the vampire king, must fight to survive in a brutal society. When she decides to enter a deadly tournament, she risks not only her life but also her heart. The trials are merciless, and the only path to victory is through the death of her competitors. But what happens when emotions get involved and trust becomes the most dangerous weapon?
Tropes:
"Hunger Games" dynamic
Father-daughter conflict
Survival competition with brutal trials
Slow-burn with emotional depth
Romance: Passion with Bite
From Blood and Ash
🔥🔥🔥🔥 (explicit, frequent scenes)
The romance between Poppy and Hawke is intense, passionate, and full of forbidden longing. Religion and morality play a significant role, adding depth to their relationship. Poppy's inner conflict between duty and desire keeps the tension high. The chemistry between the protagonists is electrifying, and the numerous intimate scenes are more than just fan service—they reflect Poppy’s growth and deepen their emotional connection.
The Serpent and the Wings of Night
🔥🔥🔥 (emotionally intense, less explicit)
While The Serpent and the Wings of Night features fewer explicit scenes, the romance builds with a slow-burning intensity that feels almost tangible. The developing relationship between Oraya and her counterpart is based on mutual respect and survival, growing organically over time. This book focuses more on trust, understanding, and self-sacrifice rather than immediate passion.
Worldbuilding: Mysticism vs. Political Power Plays
From Blood and Ash
A world shaped by gods and prophecies
Magical hierarchies featuring "Ascended" and mortal inhabitants
Bloodlines and divine powers determining the balance of power
Intrigues, lies, and political manipulation
The Serpent and the Wings of Night
A dark vampire world with a unique night-market aesthetic
Political intrigue and warring kingdoms
Magic based on shadow manipulation and ritual sacrifices
A ruthless tournament deadlier than anything Oraya has faced before
FBAA leans into an epic, almost overwhelming mythology, while TSatWoN offers a tighter, darker, and more politically intricate world.
Strengths & Weaknesses
From Blood and Ash
✅ Addictive storytelling, full of twists
✅ A charismatic yet somewhat trope-heavy couple
✅ Expansive, richly detailed fantasy world
❌ Repetitive dialogue that can become redundant
❌ Overcomplicated plotlines in later books
The Serpent and the Wings of Night
✅ Well-structured, gripping storytelling
✅ A strong father figure adding emotional depth
✅ Intelligent, well-thought-out character development
❌ Less time for character development due to the fast pace
Reader Poll: What’s Your Dark Romantasy Type?
🤍 Team FBAA: Perfect for fans of epic fantasy sagas with spice overload and dramatic plot twists.
🖤 Team TSatWoN: For those who love dark, dense stories with political intrigue and emotional depth.
Which side are you on?
Conclusion
Read From Blood and Ash if…
You enjoy long series with at least six books.
You love “Touch Her and Die” romance and sizzling scenes.
Divine prophecies and epic fantasy worlds fascinate you.
Read The Serpent and the Wings of Night if…
You prefer a standalone book with a bittersweet ending.
You’re looking for dark vampire lore beyond Twilight.
You enjoy deadly competitions and political power struggles.
Whether it’s divine fate or a bloody night—both books take dark romantasy to another level!
🗨️ Let’s Chat!
Which Romantasy type are you? Team TSatWoN or Team FBAA?
Drop your pick in the comments – I can’t wait to hear!
📚 Want More Magic?
Subscribe to the Cosmic Reads Newsletter for exclusive guides and book updates.
✨ Keep chasing stories,
– Viktoria, Your Cosmic Book Guide
